Thursday, December 02, 2010

Life Links 12/2/10

Emergency contraceptive ella is now available in the United States. Various prolife groups and individuals believe that ella, which has a similar chemical make-up to the RU-486 abortion pill, could work to prevent the implantation of a human embryos or cause abortions. Ella is currently only available with a prescription unlike Plan B which women can get without a prescription.

Creative Minority Report shares that scientists in Spain have developed microscopic bar codes which they've implanted into mouse embryos and been given approval to use in human embryos created via IVF.

The Bay Citizen has new information on the continuing troubles at the former Planned Parenthood Golden Gate.
Dian Harrison, the former chief executive of Planned Parenthood Golden Gate, has filed suit against the organization, now known as Golden Gate Community Health, for more than $180,000 in severance. The lawsuit, which was filed Nov. 22, comes as the struggling nonprofit organization is making a major fundraising push to stay afloat....

Under Harrison's leadership, the nonprofit lost $2.8 million during the 2008-2009 tax year, according to tax filings. It had not broken even since the 2005-2006 tax year, tax records show....

Meanwhile, Bay Area Planned Parenthood affiliates are racing to get services up and running in the counties where Planned Parenthood Golden Gate had operated, including those where Golden Gate Community Health continues to operate.

Frances Kissling, former president of Catholics for Free Choice, replies to Amanda Marcotte's charge that prolifers are liars and dialoguing with them is a waste of time.
When dialogue participants, including those at Princeton, hold back it's not because they are "liars" as Amanda scoldingly calls them, but because dialogue requires restraint. Setting up through words old reactive patterns is not helpful. In this regard, I am glad Amanda was not there. I wouldn't put my worst enemy in the room with someone who talked the way Amanda writes when she gets wound up about the "evil" antis.

Amanda also says you can't "have a dialogue without agreeing on the facts." In fact, you probably wouldn't need a dialogue if you agreed on the facts. Fact fights dominate the life choice debate.
Kissling also tore to shreds another RH Reality Check poster's assertions about the circumstances leading to late-term abortions.
Factually, we have no data to support these assertions. After a web search did not reveal confirmation, I emailed Guttmacher. Here is the response "[we do not] know of any data to support these assertions about reasons for abortions post 20 weeks. Reasons for second-trimester abortions may be very different than reasons for post-20-week abortions, but again there's no info. We do know that young women (minors in particular) take longer to realize they are pregnant."

Because I am prochoice I give Catherine Epstein some latitude. Some of what she speculates is reasonable. Some of it is the desire of an advocate to put the best foot forward but in my opinion strays from a rigorous approach to the "facts." We do not know if there are more late abortions due to severe fetal abnormality or to denial and fear. We have no idea if denial by young women is the result of sexual abuse, none whatsoever. Claiming that lack of funding for a first trimester abortion is resolved with finding six times more money later in the pregnancy is highly speculative.

1 comment:

  1. Wow! That is some refreshing honesty from Kissling! Praying that Truth grabs total hold of her!